Should I Stain My Hardwood Floors?

A picture of someone staining hardwood floors with a blog title that reads, "Should I stain my hardwood floors?"

To stain or not to stain — that’s the question! There’s nothing more beautiful about a home than a gleaming hardwood floor. But should you keep your floors au natural, or give in to the temptation of a little color? While staining your wood floors does have some advantages, there are also a few things to consider before taking the plunge. So if the question — “Should I stain my hardwood floors?” — has been on your mind, here’s what you need to know about staining hardwood floors.

At G3 Hardwood Flooring, a wood flooring contractor in Colorado Springs, we have worked with countless clients across the Front Range to expertly stain their hardwood floors. As hardwood flooring professionals since 1947, our team knows a thing or two about staining wood floors. So whether you’re considering staining your hardwood floors for the first time, or you’re looking to re-stain them, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons before making a decision.

Keep reading to learn more about staining hardwood floors, so you can decide what’s best for your home!

a picture of a dark hardwood stain

Advantages of Staining Wood Floors

There are a few advantages to staining your hardwood floors:

1. Enhanced Visual Appeal

One of the main reasons people choose to stain their wood floors is for the enhanced visual appeal. If you’re looking to add a little personality to your space or create a certain ambiance, staining your hardwood floors is a great way to do it. With so many different colors and shades available, the sky is the limit when it comes to creating your perfect look.

2. Increased Durability

Another advantage of staining your hardwood floors is that it can actually increase their durability. When done properly, staining creates a barrier that helps protect your floors from scratches, scuffs, and other everyday wear and tear.

3. Improved Resistance to Sunlight

If your hardwood floors are exposed to a lot of sunlight, staining them can help improve their resistance to fading and discoloration. For example, if you are thinking about staining a deck, a darker stain reflects the sun’s rays and provides better UV protection.

4. Increased Value

If you’re thinking about selling your home in the future, staining your hardwood floors can actually increase its value. Potential buyers are often willing to pay more for a home that has been well-maintained, and stained hardwood floors are a good indication that the home has been cared for. Plus, staining hardwood floors is a great way to give your home a fresh, updated look without breaking the bank.

Disadvantages of Staining Wood Floors

While there are some definite advantages to staining your wood floors, there are also a few disadvantages to consider:

1. Increased Maintenance

One downside of stained floors is that they require a bit more maintenance than unstained floors. You’ll need to be diligent about cleaning and protecting your floors to keep them looking their best. For example, you’ll need to use cleaners that are specifically designed for hardwood floors and be careful not to damage the finish. You should also avoid using harsh chemicals or abrasive scrubbers, as these can strip away the stain and leave your floors looking dull.

2. Limited Options for Repairs

If your stained floors become damaged, you may have limited options for repairing them. For example, if you have a large scratch or gouge, you may need to sand down the entire floor and restain it to achieve a consistent look. This can be costly and time-consuming, so it’s something to keep in mind before staining your floors. If you’re working on a budget, you may want to consider an option that’s less likely to require major repairs, such as laminate or vinyl flooring.

3. Not Suitable for Every Room

While stained hardwood floors can look beautiful in the right setting, they’re not always ideal for every room in your home. For example, if you have young children or pets, their messes may be more visible on stained floors. In these cases, it may be better to opt for an easier-to-clean option, such as tile or linoleum. Also, keep in mind that dark stains can make small rooms look even smaller. That means it’s important to consider the size of your space before choosing a stain color as well.

4. Staining is Time-Consuming

Another disadvantage of staining wood floors is that the process can be time-consuming. If you’re doing it yourself, you’ll need to allow for plenty of drying time between coats. You won’t be able to put down a layer of finish until the stain is completely dry, so factor that into your timeline. And if you’re hiring a professional to do the job, be prepared to have them in your home for several days making your floors perfect.

a picture of wood finishing

Considerations Before Staining Wood Floors

If you’re thinking about staining your hardwood floors, there are a few things you’ll need to take into consideration, including:

1. The Type of Wood

The first thing you’ll need to consider is the type of flooring you have. Some types of wood are better suited for staining than others. For example, hardwoods like maple and oak take hardwood stains very well, while softer woods like pine can be more difficult to work with. If you’re not sure what type of wood your floors are made of, ask a professional for help. If you’re DIYing your hardwood floor stain, a patch test would allow you to see how your wood floors will respond to the color.

2. The Style of Your Home

The style of your home will also play a role in your decision to stain your hardwood floors. For example, if you have a rustic or country-style home, darker stains may be a better fit. However, if your home is more modern, you may want to choose a lighter stain to be consistent with your aesthetic. You should also take into consideration how light filters into your home, the color of your walls, any pictures you have, and other design elements when making your decision. But remember there is no wrong choice when it comes to the hardwood flooring color you love!

3. The Condition of Your Floors

Another important consideration is the condition of your floors. If your floors are in good shape, staining them is likely to be a straightforward process. However, if your floors are older or in poor condition, you may want to think twice about staining them. That’s because the stain can highlight any imperfections in the wood, making them more visible. If you do decide to stain your floors, you may want to invest in some repairs first to get the best results.

4. The Cost

Finally, you’ll need to consider the cost of staining your hardwood floors. If you’re doing it yourself, the cost will largely depend on the type of stain and finish you choose. If you’re hiring a professional to do the job, you can expect to pay anywhere from $2 to $5 per square foot. Ultimately, the cost will come down to your personal preferences and budget.

a picture of wood staining sponge

Get Professional Wood Floor Refinishing With G3 Hardwood Flooring

If you are ready for a change, staining your floors is just another way to dramatically change the look of your home. However, there are some disadvantages to staining hardwood floors. For example, you may want to hold off if you have softer wood floors or damage like deep scratches. So, if you are asking yourself, “Should I stain my hardwood floors”, these considerations can help you come to a decision.

If you’re wondering if you should stain your wood floors, the experts at G3 Hardwood Flooring can help. We specialize in hardwood floor refinishing and can provide you with the perfect color to match your home’s style. No matter if you prefer light, dark, or colorful wood, we have a stain for you. Plus, we can even help repair any damage to your floors before we get started. Contact us today to schedule a consultation!